What to Look for in a Shopify Email Automation Tool

1. Klaviyo: Best Overall for Shopify Email Automation

2. Omnisend: Best Value for Small-to-Mid Shopify Stores

3. Shopify Email: Best Free Starting Point

4. ActiveCampaign: Best for Advanced Multi-Channel Automation

5. Mailchimp: Most Recognized Name, Read the Fine Print

6. Drip: Best All-in-One E-Commerce Marketing Suite

7. Seguno: Best for Simplicity

8. Privy: Best for List Building and Basic Automation

9. Brevo: Best for Budget-Conscious Stores

10. AiTrillion: Best Emerging All-in-One with AI Features

Estimated Monthly Pricing by Subscriber Count

Which Platform Should You Choose?

The 5 Shopify Email Automations Flows You Should Set Up First

No matter which tool you end up choosing, I'd say five automations do most of the heavy lifting when it comes to email-attributed revenue: welcome series, abandoned cart, post-purchase, browse abandonment, and customer winback.

1. Welcome Series

2. Abandoned Cart Recovery

3. Post-Purchase Flow

4. Browse Abandonment

5. Customer Winback

AIf you're already using an email marketing platform but it's no longer the right fit, switching to a new tool doesn't have to mean losing your subscribers, data, or automations. A rushed migration, however, can hurt your sender reputation and break workflows that are already performing well. Here's the sequence I'd follow to make the transition as smooth as possible.

1. Export Everything You Need

Before you cancel your old platform, export your contacts, tags, segments, custom fields, suppression lists, email templates, and historical campaign data. It's also worth documenting every automation, including triggers, delays, conditions, and goals, so you can recreate them accurately.

2. Set Up and Test Your New Platform

Authenticate your sending domain by configuring SPF, DKIM, and DMARC before sending any campaigns. Then rebuild your key automations and test them thoroughly. Make sure welcome emails, abandoned cart flows, post-purchase sequences, forms, discount codes, and dynamic content all work exactly as expected.

3. Transition Gradually

Instead of switching everything overnight, move your campaigns and automations over in stages. Keep your previous platform available until you're confident the new one is working correctly, but avoid sending the same campaigns from both platforms to the same subscribers.

4. Build Sending Volume Carefully

Start by emailing your most engaged subscribers, then gradually increase your sending volume over the following days or weeks. This helps maintain strong deliverability, especially if you're using a new sending infrastructure or dedicated IP.

5. Monitor Performance Closely

After the migration, keep a close eye on your key metrics, including deliverability, click rates, conversions, and revenue from your automated flows. Compare them with your historical benchmarks to catch any issues early.

Common Migration Mistakes to Avoid

The most common problems come from importing outdated contact lists, forgetting to migrate suppression lists, assuming segments will transfer automatically, or skipping testing before going live. Taking the time to clean your data and verify every automation will save you far more time than fixing problems after launch.

Final thoughts

avatar
Irene Le

Content Manager at TrueProfit & eCommerce Marketing Specialist

Irene Le

Irene Le is the Content Manager at TrueProfit, specializing in crafting insightful, data-driven content to help eCommerce merchants scale profitably. With over 5 years of experience in content creation and growth strategy for the eCommerce industry, she is dedicated to producing high-value, actionable content that empowers merchants to make informed financial decisions.

Let's Collaborate